Berry Online

A blog for Dr. Brian Carroll's journalism classes at Berry College

28.4.06

MySpace.com traffic among the very top

April 17, 2006
MySpace Is Unprofessional, but That's the Point

By TOM ZELLER JR., New York Times
WHEN the market research firm Nielsen/Net Ratings released its collection of Web metrics for March last Wednesday, it included, as it usually does, a list of the "Top 10 Web Sites by Brand."

The category, by way of explanation, is a measure of the "unduplicated audience that visits a property" — in this case a brand — which is defined as "a consolidation of multiple domains and U.R.L.'s that has a consistent collection of branded content."

(Sorry. Walk it off.)

Under that sort of calculus, you would expect to find the usual suspects, and they are represented: Yahoo, Microsoft, MSN, Google and AOL dominate the top five slots on the list — precisely as they did one year ago. But sneaking onto the list at No. 10 last month was MySpace, that marvel of online social networking and virtual self-expression that in two years has gone from practical obscurity to a $580 million property. That is what the News Corporation, the media conglomerate run by Rupert Murdoch, paid last year for the service, which provides millions of users with the space and tools to create personal Web sites, maintain blogs, post pictures and link their space to that of other users, forming virtual networks of cyberfriends.

"MySpace.com," the site's motto reads. "A place for friends."

Of course, there is perhaps no clearer sign of a successful business model than popular disdain, so it is no wonder that a lively trade in anti-MySpace sentiment has already taken shape.

THIS includes everything from T-shirts that bear the simple slogan: "Tom is not my friend" (a reference to Tom Anderson, the co-founder of MySpace and his cutesy habit of adding himself, and his visage, to every new member's "friends" list) to thriving, pile-on discussions among veteran Web users who find the design skills of many MySpacers to be, well, so 1995.

"Visit any random profile on MySpace, and you are instantly beamed back to the Bad Old Days of Web design, with flashing graphics, unreadable text and — worse — random songs that start playing unbidden," wrote John August, a screenwriter from Los Angeles, in his blog last week.

It is a common complaint against the behemoth — "the Google of social networking," as Mr. August put it — which now has something on the order of 50 million users.

That is, for all of the hand-wringing that parents and the press do over cyberpredators and other dangers attending the MySpace phenomenon, a much more passionate undercurrent of MySpace invective is fed by a simpler lament: Why, critics ask, must the most popular social networking site on the planet be typified by a garish, kitchen-sink aesthetic and a girls-gone-wild I.Q.?

That appears to be at least partly behind the grievances expressed by two revolutionaries identifying themselves as Katie McIntyre and Casey Primeau. They have published a little online "manifesto" that explains why, in their opinion, MySpace does something that I am not really at liberty to describe in these pages. The title of the manifesto concludes with "and So Do You," with suitable misanthropy.

Among the reasons for MySpace's lameness, according to the manifesto, are My- Space features like "Cool New People" ("Why anyone would label these folks 'Cool' is beyond our comprehension"); the "About Me" section ("Chances are no one comes to your MySpace to learn about how you 'dont hav much 2 say' about yourself"); and, of course, Tom ("How does a lonely, single nerd become the antichrist of the Internet?").

"We hate MySpace with a fiery passion, and are in full approval of a support group for each and every MySpace member," the pair concludes. "And by support group, we mean a chainsaw to the face."

A similar subtlety can be found on anti-MySpace sites like WorstOfMySpace.com.

The site makes occasional nominations for the most haphazard, graphically overindulged MySpace pages, and the most recent candidate (snipurl.com/JesusCowboy) exemplifies the sort of Frankenstein creation that critics find deserving of scorn.

It is a frenzy of animated devotional graphics and random bits of scripture set to the pulsating rhythms of the Christian rock band Petra. The word "Jesus" rains down the page in an effect that the proprietor of WorstOfMySpace describes as having been "cool for a day back in 1997" and "cheesier than an episode of 'Blossom.' "

And of course MySpace disdain was palpable last week at Slashdot, the den of techno-sophisticates.

"Ugh, no thanks," wrote one user, 19thNervousBreakdown, responding to news of the Nielsen Top 10. "That place is the most awful cesspool on the Internet." It is the kind of place, he suggested, where one finds "girls with six inches of cake makeup posing for cleavage shots, guys dressed up like Gotti with one eyebrow raised, and the most inane, unintelligible comments imaginable."

ANOTHER user, Firehed, suggested that "anyone publishing content should have an understanding of the medium on which it's being published," adding that those unfamiliar with basic Web page design "really shouldn't be putting stuff online and thinking highly of themselves, as the MySpacers tend to."

But therein, defenders of MySpace say, lies the rub.

"Because most people have terrible design sense, most profiles look pretty terrible," Mr. August, the screenwriter, noted, "but they look exactly how the user wants them to look. This element of self-expression is a large part of why teens and tweens and twenty-somethings love their MySpace."

Indeed, one can reasonably argue that MySpacers do not fancy themselves A-list designers and programmers, nor professional photographers or wits. It is "a place for friends," after all. Aesthetes and code-snobs need not apply.

"MySpace is popular BECAUSE it doesn't look 'professional,' " wrote Robert Scoble, Microsoft's "technical evangelist," in a discussion of the topic on his blog last month. "It's approachable."

Just approach with caution.

"Yes, there are some horrific sites out there that are completely standards incompliant, that are garish, that cause your browser to crash, that take an hour to load and have horrific Celine Dion music in the background," wrote a Slashdot user called Transmogrify_UK, in a stirring defense of MySpace on Friday, "but does it really matter?"

Privacy v. National Security

April 28, 2006
Trade Group Confirms Deal With Tiny Firm for ID Cards
By ERIC LIPTON, NY Times, p. A20

WASHINGTON, April 27 — A small biometrics company, whose board includes former Homeland Security Secretary Tom Ridge, stands to profit from a provision that a powerful Republican congressman wrote into budget law last year.

The law mandates that the Homeland Security Department hire a trade group, the American Association of Airport Executives and its Transportation Security Clearinghouse division, to manage what could turn into contracts together worth hundreds of millions of dollars for a new airport-security program and to issue tamperproof identification cards to millions of transportation workers.

Critics of the provision, written into an appropriation bill at the request of Representative Harold Rogers, the Kentucky Republican who is chairman of the House appropriations subcommittee that oversees domestic security, have questioned how the association, with little experience in high-technology secure identifications and biometrics, could handle such a task.

An executive at the association confirmed in a meeting and conference call among industry officials on Thursday that its clearinghouse had a partnership agreement with Daon, a biometrics company in Dublin, Ireland, according to a transcript of the meeting.

"The partnership with Daon, which is an operational one and related to the clearinghouse, it is really in the interest of making this program successful," said Carter Morris, senior vice president at the airport group, according to the transcript of the call.

The disclosure outraged other potential bidders for the work.

"It is very bad public policy to have an earmark that steers critical aspects of this key national security program to a private organization," said Walter G. Hamilton, chairman of the International Biometric Industry Association.

Daon, backed by Dermot Desmond, one of Ireland's most well-known entrepreneurs, identified landing business with the Homeland Security Department as a crucial corporate strategy nearly three years ago. The company, which has an office in Reston, Va., was a co-sponsor last year of an airport-security conference and a golf outing in Ireland organized by the American Association of Airport Executives. Mr. Rogers attended the conference, a trip paid by the airport group. Mr. Rogers has a long association with the group, receiving thousands of dollars in contributions for his election campaigns over the years and taking other trips to its annual meetings in Hawaii and California.

Mr. Ridge, while homeland security secretary, promoted using technology that relied on fingerprints, the eye iris or face shapes to confirm identities. Since he left the department in February 2004, he has advised companies in related businesses, including Savi Technology, which makes high-tech ship container-security devices.

A spokeswoman for Mr. Ridge, S. Michele Nix, confirmed that he was on the Daon board. She added that Mr. Ridge was not even aware of the language in question being written into the appropriation bill.

The chief executive officer at Daon, Thomas A. Grissen, did not reply on Thursday to messages on his voice mail and with staff members in Reston.

Biometrics is a fast-growing field filled with many small venture-capital-based companies like Daon that are furiously competing for a chunk of the billions of dollars in potential domestic security contracts.

The Transportation Worker Identification Credential program and a separate program, Registered Traveler, which allows airline passengers to move faster than normal through security checkpoints, are two of the biggest targets for those companies. The provision arranged by Mr. Rogers mandates that the Homeland Security Department hire the aviation group for the "purposes of collecting and aggregating biometric data necessary for background vetting; providing all associated record keeping, customer service, and related functions" for both contracts.

Mr. Rogers said he had added the mandate because the aviation group proven in the last four years that it could help the government with security-related background checks for airport workers. The Homeland Security Department is at least two years behind in introducing similar check for other transportation workers, including those at ports.

"There is absolutely no reason to waste more time and money reinventing the wheel," Mr. Rogers said Wednesday, in explaining the mandate, which the Homeland Security Department and others in the Bush administration opposed. His spokeswoman, Leslie Cupp, did not respond to a request for comment on Thursday.

Other biometrics companies are seeking to have the provision rescinded or removed in the budget bill this year.

Physical v. Virtual Community: wiring a city for wireless

April 28, 2006
Suffolk County Plans to Offer Free Wireless Internet Access
By BRUCE LAMBERT, NY Times, p. A20

Suffolk County is planning a wireless system to provide free access to the Internet to the 1.5 million residents who live throughout its 900 square miles. It would be one of the largest government-sponsored wireless networks in the nation.

The system would allow anyone to use computers and P.D.A. devices with wireless capabilities anywhere in the county, and would also be available to visitors, businesses, government agencies, institutions and groups. County officials hope to start installation next year.

"People could connect to the Internet anytime, any place," said Suffolk County Executive Steve Levy, who proposed the plan. A private company selected by the county would build the system at no cost to taxpayers and finance it by selling Internet advertising or by charging a fee for connections with a faster speed.

Mr. Levy has appointed a 15-member committee to draft the details of the plan. There is strong support for the idea in the county legislature.

The potential uses are virtually endless, proponents say. People could flip open a laptop and surf the Web while at the beach, pull over and park to check their route on MapQuest, get a head start on office e-mail while commuting to work on the train or pause on the golf course to track stock prices by glancing at a P.D.A. device.

With Suffolk's extensive shoreline and the popularity of boating, officials are even exploring beaming signals over the water. "It's something we're thinking about," said Sharon Cates-Williams, Mr. Levy's information technology commissioner.

As envisioned, the combined area and population of Suffolk's network would make it bigger than any other local network now in existence in the nation, experts say.

But many other cities and counties are pursuing similar projects, including an even larger proposal pending in Chicago that would cover 940 square miles where five million people live. San Francisco and Philadelphia, much smaller in area and population, are also working on plans for wireless networks.

The scramble to create municipal wireless or Wi-Fi systems has provoked sharp debate. Critics question whether the systems should be run by government or private industry.

Some cities with networks have allowed private companies to create the networks on public property with an agreement that the cost to users would be minimal or free.

Telephone and cable television companies have blocked some efforts, calling them unfair competition with their own business of selling wired connections. But now some of those same companies are bidding to build and operate the new government-sponsored systems. On Long Island, Cablevision offers some paid wireless service to its subscribers but says it will explore Suffolk's proposal

Other concerns have been raised about privacy and security for users of the new networks. And some skeptics dispute the popular model of free service as being ill-advised.

Typically, wireless systems have caught on in remote areas without any other Internet access and in urban centers with high population densities that concentrate potential users.

But Suffolk is distinctly different, a sprawling county with heavily developed suburbs, gilded estates, horse farms, semi-rural sections with potato farms and vineyards, strip malls and seashores. It stretches from the office and retail corridor along Route 110 on its western border to the Montauk Lighthouse on the East End and beyond to Fishers Island.

Covering that area would require hundreds or thousands of transmitting devices that cost up to $5,000 each, experts say. The broadcast range varies, and more transmitters are needed in areas of heavy usage. The entire system could cost tens of millions of dollars, experts say.

Government agencies are eager to use wireless networks for themselves. County officials also say the network will help promote the local economy by providing easy Internet access to businesses and especially to mobile workers. Another goal is to close the so-called digital divide for low-income people who cannot afford computer connection fees.

While the signals generally do not penetrate buildings, booster devices costing about $100 up to $200 can extend the service inside. Adapters enabling the wireless connection are included in many new computers or can be added.

"Wireless is an incredible tool that every community needs to look at if not endorse," said Craig J. Settles, a consultant in Oakland, Calif., and author of "Fighting the Good Fight for Municipal Wireless" (Hudson House, 2006). "We're in an economy that is increasingly Internet-centric. Everything from dating to dying is being done in one form or another by Internet."

Today’s Learner by Age 21 (source unknown; received from Berry OIT)

  • 10,000 hours on video games
  • 200,000 emails
  • 20,000 hours of TV
  • 10,000 hours on cell phones
  • Under 5,000 hours reading
  • Expect constant communications (IM, cell, email, text messaging, voice, pictures, and soon video).
  • Have lots and lots of portable music (MP3 players, CD players).
  • 100% use the Internet for information on colleges, careers and job (plus a whole lot of other things).
  • 94% use the Internet for school research.
  • 56% prefer using the Internet to the telephone.
  • On-line gaming is fast becoming a very popular activity.

Some Conclusions on Today’s Students

  • Digitally literate (on things that interest them).
  • Always “on” and connected to someone or some place.
  • Mobile.
  • Expect individualized services (MP3, cell phones, RSS feeds)
  • Experiential in nature.
  • Community-oriented; like working in groups.
  • Trust adults and typically are involved in family purchases.
  • Multi-tasking (listening to MP3s while watching TV and doing homework).
  • Games are a way of life ($10 billion in sales in 2002).
  • Learn by experimenting (What, read the manual first?).
  • Text and image learners (discovery, experiential, bricolage and judgment)


TV Generation

PC Generation

Network Generation

Web

What is it?

Web is cool

Web is Oxygen

Community

Personal

Extended Personal

Virtual

Conversation

Private (phone booth)

Semi-private

Anywhere; doesn’t matter

Perspective

Local

Multi-National

Global

Career

One

Multiple

Multiple Reinvention

Loyalty

Corporation

Self

Soul

Authority

Hierarchy

Unimpressed

Self as Expert

MySpace.com and memorials to folks who have died

Rituals of Grief Go Online
By WARREN ST. JOHN, New York Times
p. A1
April 27, 2006

Like many other 23-year-olds, Deborah Lee Walker loved the beach, discovering bands, making new friends and keeping up with old ones, often through the social networking site MySpace.com, where she listed her heroes as "my family, and anyone serving in the military — thank you!"

So only hours after she died in an automobile accident near Valdosta, Ga., early on the morning of Feb. 27, her father, John Walker, logged onto her MySpace page with the intention of alerting her many friends to the news. To his surprise, there were already 20 to 30 comments on the page lamenting his daughter's death. Eight weeks later, the comments are still coming.

"Hey Lee! It's been a LONG time," a friend named Stacey wrote recently. "I know that you will be able to read this from Heaven, where I'm sure you are in charge of the parties. Please rest in peace and know that it will never be the same here without you!"

Just as the Web has changed long-established rituals of romance and socializing, personal Web pages on social networking sites that include MySpace, Xanga.com and Facebook.com are altering the rituals of mourning. Such sites have enrolled millions of users in recent years, especially the young, who use them to expand their personal connections and to tell the wider world about their lives.

Inevitably, some of these young people have died — prematurely, in accidents, suicides, murders and from medical problems — and as a result, many of their personal Web pages have suddenly changed from lighthearted daily dairies about bands or last night's parties into online shrines where grief is shared in real time.

The pages offer often wrenching views of young lives interrupted, and in the process have created a dilemma for bereaved parents, who find themselves torn between the comfort derived from having access to their children's private lives and staying in contact with their friends, and the unease of grieving in a public forum witnessed by anyone, including the ill-intentioned.

"The upside is definitely that we still have some connection with her and her friends," said Bob Shorkey, a graphic artist in North Carolina whose 24-year-old stepdaughter, Katie Knudson, was killed on Feb. 23 in a drive-by shooting in Fort Myers, Fla. "But because it's public, your life is opened up to everyone out there, and that's definitely the downside."

It's impossible to know how many people with pages on social networking sites have died; 74 million people have registered with MySpace alone, according to the company, which said it does not delete pages for inactivity. But a glib and sometimes macabre site called MyDeathSpace.com has documented at least 116 people with profiles on MySpace who have died. There are additions to the list nearly every day.

Last Thursday, for example, a 17-year-old from Vancouver, Wash., named Anna Svidersky was stabbed to death while working at a McDonald's there. As word of the crime spread among her extended network of friends on MySpace, her page was filled with posts from distraught friends and affected strangers. A separate page set up by Ms. Svidersky's friends after her death received about 1,200 comments in its first three days.

"Anna, you were a great girl and someone very special," one person wrote. "I enjoyed having you at our shows and running into you at the mall. You will be missed greatly ... rest in peace."

Tom Anderson, the president of MySpace, said in an e-mail message that out of concern for privacy, the company did not allow people to assume control of the MySpace accounts of users after their deaths.

"MySpace handles each incident on a case-by-case basis when notified, and will work with families to respect their wishes," Mr. Anderson wrote, adding that at the request of survivors the company would take down pages of deceased users.

Friends of MySpace users who have died said they had been comforted by the messages left by others and by the belief or hope that their dead friends might somehow be reading from another realm. And indeed many of the posts are written as though the recipient were still alive.

"I still believe that even though she's not the one on her MySpace page, that's a way I can reach out to her," said Jenna Finke, 23, a close friend of Ms. Walker, the young woman who died in Georgia. "Her really close friends go on there every day. It means a lot to know people aren't forgetting about her."

More formal online obituary services have been available for a number of years. An Illinois company called Legacy.com has deals with many newspapers, including The New York Times, to create online guest books for obituaries the papers publish on the Web, and offers multimedia memorials called Living Tributes starting at $29. But Web pages on social networking sites are more personal, the online equivalent of someone's room, and maintaining them has its complications. Some are frustratingly mundane.

Amanda Presswood, whose 23-year-old friend Michael Olsen was killed in a fire in Galesburg, Ill., on Jan. 23, said none of his friends or family members knew or could guess the password to his MySpace account, which he signed onto the day before he died. That made it impossible to accept some new messages.

"There's a lot of pictures on there that people haven't seen," Ms. Presswood said. "His parents have been coming to me for help because they know I know about the Internet. They even asked if I could hack it so I could keep the page going."

The Walkers correctly guessed the password to their daughter's page, and used it to alert her friends to details of her memorial service. They also used it to access photographs and stories about their daughter they had missed out on.

"It's a little weird to say as a parent, but the site has been a source for us to get to know her better," Mr. Walker said. "We didn't understand the breadth and scope of the network she had built as an individual, and we got to see that through MySpace. It helped us to understand the impact she's had on other people."

At the same time, Ms. Walker's mother, Julie, wrote in an e-mail message, the family was overwhelmed by unsolicited e-mail messages from strangers offering platitudes and seeking to advise them on how to handle their grief. The family found such offerings unwelcome, however well intentioned.

"The grief of our own friends and family is almost more than we can bear on top of our own, and we don't need anyone else's on our shoulders," Mrs. Walker wrote.

Mr. Shorkey said he and his wife remained in touch with their daughter's friends through MySpace. And they visit her Web page daily.

"Some days it makes me feel she's still there," he said. "And some days it reminds me I can never have that contact again."